The secret of a supervolcano

“Researchers have now found an explanation for what triggered the largest volcanic eruption witnessed by mankind. The volcano’s secret was revealed by geochemical clues hidden inside volcanic quartz crystals”.

-The weekly newsletter of the Geochemical Society, Jan 31st 2017

An animation I made to summarise our work on Toba supervolcano, published in January 2017 in the journal Scientific Reports.

Below you can read a summary of our recently published work on Toba supervolcano, that also appeared in Swedish on Uppsala University’s website here.

The secret of a supervolcano

The deadliest volcanoes on earth are called supervolcanoes, capable of producing cataclysmic eruptions that devastate huge regions, and cause global cooling of the climate. The Indonesian supervolcano Toba had one of these eruptions about 73 000 years ago, when 2 800 cubic kilometers of volcanic ash was ejected into the atmosphere and rained down and covered enormous areas in Indonesia and India.

 Scientists have long debated how these extraordinary volumes of magma are generated, and what makes this magma erupt so very explosively. A team of researchers at Uppsala University, together with international colleagues, have now found intriguing clues hidden inside millimeter-sized crystals from the volcanic ash and rock.

The researchers analysed quartz crystals from Toba, and found a distinct shift in the isotopic composition towards the outer rim of the crystals.

The researchers analysed quartz crystals from Toba, and found a distinct shift in the isotopic composition towards the outer rims of the crystals. Photo: Budd et al.

‘Quartz crystals that grow in the magma register chemical and thermodynamical changes in the magmatic system prior to eruption, similar to how tree rings record climate variations. When the conditions in the magma change, the crystals respond and produce distinct growth zones that record these changes. The problem is that each “tree ring”-analogue is only a few micrometers across, which is why they are extremely challenging to analyse in detail,’ says Dr. David Budd at the Department of Earth Sciences, Uppsala University.

The researchers analysed quartz crystals from Toba, and found a distinct shift in the isotopic composition towards the outer rim of the crystals. The crystal rims contain a relatively lower proportion of the heavy isotope 18O compared to the lighter 16O.

‘The low ratio of 18O to 16O contents in the crystal rims indicate that something in the magmatic system changed drastically just before the big eruption. The explanation behind these chemical signatures is that the magma melted and assimilated a large volume of a local rock that itself is characterised by a relatively low ratio of 18O to 16O. This rock type also often contains a lot of water, which may be released into the magma, producing steam, and thereby an increased gas pressure inside the magma chamber. This rapidly increased gas pressure eventually allowed the magma to rupture the overlying crust, and send thousands of cubic kilometres of magma into the atmosphere,’ explains Dr. Frances Deegan at the Department of Earth Sciences, Uppsala University.

Luckily, these cataclysmic super-eruptions happen very rarely.

‘Biologists have previously shown that this particular eruption at Toba pushed humanity close to extinction. It will hopefully take many thousands of years, but the fact is it is only a matter of time before the next super eruption, maybe at Toba, Yellowstone (USA), or somewhere else. Hopefully, we will know more and be better prepared next time!’ says Professor Valentin Troll at the Department of Earth Sciences, who led this study of Toba quartzes at Uppsala University.

Budd, D.A., Troll, V.R., Deegan, D.M., Jolis, E.M., Smith, V.C., Whitehouse, M.J., Harris, C., Freda, C., Hilton, D.R., Halldórsson, S.A., & Bindeman, I.N. (2017) Magma reservoir dynamics at Toba caldera, Indonesia, recorded by oxygen isotope zoning in quartz. Scientific Reports | 7:40624 | DOI: 10.1038/srep40624 1

Volcanoes as probes of the Earth

A little while ago, I spoke with Annica Hulth from Uppsala University about volcano research in Uppsala. It was a lovely experience to take part in an interview about my research. The piece written by Annica is below.   

Volcanoes both fascinate and frighten people because of the beautiful landforms they create and the powerful force of volcanic eruptions. Studies of rock, minerals, and gas erupted from volcanoes enable researchers to look into the earth’s interior and help to provide important information to people who live close to active volcanoes.

Frances Deegan is part of a research team at the Department of Earth Sciences which specialises in volcanoes. She is a geochemist and studies the interaction between magma and limestone in volcanoes in various parts of the world.

She has been, for example, to Merapi in Indonesia and Vesuvius in Italy, which are still active volcanoes in carbonate-rich areas. Some of her work is done in the laboratory where she analyses samples of solidified magma.

“Crystals that grew in magma are fascinating because they can record the history of the volcano including where magma is born, how it is transported to the surface, and what processes it undergoes on the way,” says Frances Deegan.

Pyroxene crystals from Merapi volcano, viewed under a Scanning Electron Microscope. Micron-scale chemical analysis of crystals reveals information about magma chamber processes, magma storage, and magma supply beneath volcanoes.

“I also love to replicate volcanic processes experimentally in the lab and I am interested in how gases released from volcanoes can affect earth’s atmosphere and climate.”

When carbon dioxide bubbles up

This was the subject of the most recent study, which was carried out in collaboration with Italian and Swedish researchers. The team showed experimentally what happens when carbonate-rich rocks such as limestone and marble come into contact with magma beneath volcanoes.

Small capsules containing limestone and crushed lava were put in an oven and subjected to the same intense pressure and temperature as exists underneath volcanoes.

“The results were very bubbly,” says Frances, “just like when you put a sparkling vitamin C tablet into a glass of water.”

Bang! Scanning electron microscope image of an experiment showing how CO2 bubbles are released when magma comes into contact with limestone (source: F.M. Deegan, Uppsala University).

The bubbles were CO2 which are generated when magma meets limestone and eventually comes up to the earth’s surface and then out into the atmosphere.

“This is interesting because it can help scientists to learn more about the natural carbon cycle, which is very important especially since humans are currently interacting with such cycles on earth,” says Frances Deegan.

All kinds of volcanoes studied

The research team studies all possible kinds of volcanoes in every part of the world. These might be oceanic islands such as the Canary Islands or Cape Verde, subduction zone volcanoes such as Vesuvius, active volcanoes in Iceland and Indonesia or very old extinct volcanoes such as in the Canadian High Arctic, Ireland and Great Britain. Some of the researchers also study African volcanoes, for example in Cameroon.

An article was released recently about the Icelandic volcano Holuhraun and one of the world’s most closely monitored volcanic eruptions. It was not a violent eruption but it could have gone badly if the magma had taken another route through the bedrock. The eruption started under ice but instead of going straight up – which would have led to a more explosive eruption – the magma went 45 km towards the north-east and came up to the surface at Holuhraun, just beyond the edge of the glacier.

Many live close to volcanoes

In the above case, there was nobody who lived close to the volcano. The eruption, however, did attract many tourists who came to watch. In other parts of the world, it is common to find major cities close to active volcanoes, for example, Naples and the volcano Vesuvius in Italy.

“Research on volcanoes can help the people living nearby to understand them better and hence to be better prepared for an eruption. Volcanoes are extremely hazardous and yet many people live near them – learning about how they work is therefore not only very interesting but it is also necessary,” says Frances Deegan.

The study of volcanoes is built upon international collaboration and is of great help to local researchers who, for example, can record signals from volcanoes using different measuring instruments.

“We can’t predict eruptions, but we can try to be prepared for the type of eruption that may happen. Some volcanoes are very explosive and others not so dangerous. And all volcanoes have different personalities,” says Frances Deegan.

Annica Hulth

A version of this article appeared on UU’s website here and an article about our most recent research into limestone assimilation published in the journal Scientific Reports, can be found by clicking here.

Holuhraun 2014-15 eruption

We wrote a short piece about recent research on the products of the 2014-2015 Holuhraun eruption on Iceland, which was published on Uppsala University’s website. Here is a modified version below – happy reading!

Holuhraun – the volcanic eruption that captured the imagination of a nation.

Immortalised in Icelandic stamps and a huge tourist attraction, the 2014 Holuhraun eruption also received the attention of the world’s volcanology community. Indeed, the Holuhraun eruption can easily be regarded as one of the best ever monitored eruptions. Geophysicists tracked the movement of magma beneath the ground surface in outstanding detail in the run-up to eruption. Now, on the second birthday of the Holuhraun eruption, a team of scientists from Uppsala University, Sweden and the University of Cape Town, South Africa, deliver new information about the generation of the Holuhraun magma from the crystals it contained, which record the magma’s journey like little flight recorders due to their progressive growth during magma storage, ascent, and eruption.

stamp
Icelandic stamp to commemorate the 2014-2015 Holuhraun eruption. Photo: Íslandspóstur

What do the crystals reveal? Harri Geiger, a PhD student at Uppsala University and lead author of a new paper published in the American Geophysical Union journal, Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems, explains:

“By studying their chemistry, we can decipher at what depth the crystals were formed and where they stalled on their way to the surface. With this information we can reconstruct how the magma travelled upward and laterally in the weeks prior to the eruption”.

holuhraun-lava-thin-section
Crystals in lava from Holuhraun viewed under a light polarising microscope.

Magma was transported to the eruption site

Harri goes on to explain that crystals were born and stored at multiple levels in the crust, over a depth range of 28 to 5 km beneath the nearby Bárðarbunga volcano before the magma was siphoned off and transported laterally, through the Earth’s upper crust, to the Holuhraun eruption site.

The Uppsala group even found evidence that part of the magma was recycled from older crystalline material, likely from beneath the Bárðarbunga central volcano some 45 km to the SW of the eruption site. In fact, Bárðarbunga’s central crater deepened before the eruption at Holuhraun, implying that magma beneath Bárðarbunga volcano was transported away and added to the rising stream of molten rock towards Holuhraun.

New knowledge about volcanic processes

The research results by the Uppsala group are consistent with the extensive geophysical data, but they lend a new dimension to our understanding of sub-surface processes occurring before the eruption at Holuhraun. The study by Geiger and co-workers shows that magma can be tapped from multiple storage regions beneath the surface and merged into a final erupted product, thus providing an exciting new addition to our knowledge of volcanic processes on Iceland.

“This is something we need to keep in mind for future Icelandic eruptions, especially where large central volcanoes like Bárðarbunga are located close to where the crust is rifting, as was the case at Holuhraun”, says Harri Geiger.

geiger-summary-cartoon
Cartoon showing the magma supply system beneath Bardarbunga and Holuhraun. Modified after Geiger et al. 2016.

 

 —

Facts

The research was supported by the Swedish Research Council (VR) and the Center for Natural Disaster Sciences (CNDS) at Uppsala University.

Read the article:

Geiger, H., Mattsson, T., Deegan, F.M., Troll, V.R., Burchardt, S., Gudmundsson, O., Tryggvason, A., Krumbholz, M., Harris, C. (2016) Magma plumbing for the 2014-2015 Holuhraun eruption, Iceland, Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems

Arctic adventures

For my first post I thought I’d share a few memories from my Arctic 2015 adventure. Its coming up to a year since I undertook field work in the Canadian High Arctic with Prof. Valentin R. Troll (Uppsala University) and Dr. Jean Bédard (Geological Survey of Canada) and it was one of the most unforgettable experiences in my life.

We wrote a piece for Geology Today about our trip and why we went there:

Geology Today

I will post some more arctic pictures again soon, but for now here is a picture of me sampling an evaporite dome:

DSCN0201

And here is what our base camp looked like for a few days:

DSCN0650

Total wilderness, complete with private beach!

Fiord and camp_flycamp1_FMD

And beautiful geological features like these textures in gypsum:

weather in evaporite_flycamp1_FMD

Ellesmere and Axel Heiberg Islands are beautiful places on our planet. We’ve just started our research project about magma-crust interaction in the High Arctic and links to paleo-climate. I will try to keep this site updated with future developments! 🙂

 

Frances

A blog about my research in geology & volcanology